01-0573R

RESOLUTION AFFIRMING THE DECISION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS TO DENY A REQUEST TO CONSTRUCT FIVE DWELLINGS ON PARCELS OF PROPERTY REDUCING THE REQUIRED LOT AREA FOR 2 DWELLINGS FROM 5,000 SQUARE FEET TO 3,000 SQUARE FEET; 2 DWELLINGS TO 3,500 SQUARE FEET AND 1 DWELLING TO 3,600 SQUARE FEET; TO REDUCE THE REQUIRED FRONTAGE ON A MAINTAINABLE STREET FOR EACH LOT FROM 50' TO 30', 35' AND 36' RESPECTIVELY; AND TO RELAX THE FRONT YARD SETBACK FROM 25' TO 10', THE CORNER SIDE YARD SETBACK FROM 15' TO 9, AND THE AGGREGATE SIDE YARD SETBACK FROM 12' TO 10' ON PROPERTY LOCATED AT 5109-5119 RAMSEY ST.

BY COUNCILOR STENBERG:

        WHEREAS, Deede Westermann, Executive Director of SVCNDA (Spirit Valley Citizens' Neighborhood Development Association) has appealed the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals to deny variances to construct five dwellings on parcels of property reducing the required lot area for 2 dwellings from 5,000 square feet to 3,000 square feet; 2 dwellings to 3,500 square feet and 1 dwelling to 3,600 square feet; to reduce the required frontage on a maintainable street for each lot from 50' to 30', 35' and 36' respectively; and to relax the front yard setback from 25' to 10', the corner side yard setback from 15' to 9, and the aggregate side yard setback from 12' to 10'; and

        WHEREAS, the property is located within an R-2 Two-Family Residential zoning district; and

        WHEREAS, Chapter 50-20.2 requires a minimum lot size of 5,000 square feet, 50' minimum frontage and a minimum front yard setback of 25' for dwellings in an R-2 zoning district; and

        WHEREAS, Chapter 50-23(f) states that when a lot of record on July 14, 1958, is less than 50' in width, no side yard shall be less than 5'; and

        WHEREAS, Chapter 50-23(a) requires a minimum side yard setback on a corner lot of 15' for dwellings; and

        WHEREAS, Chapter 50-23(i) requires a minimum aggregate side yard setback of 12'; and

        WHEREAS, the board of zoning appeals denied the variance requests because it found that no hardship to the property existed which constituted special circumstances or conditions applying to the building or land in question which was peculiar to such property and did not apply generally to other land or buildings in the vicinity, and because it was not necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of a substantial property right and not merely a convenience of the applicant; and

        WHEREAS, the board of zoning appeals is not a legislative body and cannot rewrite current code; and

        WHEREAS, the granting of this variance was not justified under the existing verbiage of the zoning code; and

        WHEREAS, the tool which could allow this project, the community unit plan has been repealed; and

        WHEREAS, dwellings could be built on the site which would comply with current code; and

        WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 50-47 of the Duluth City Code, 1959, as amended, in order to grant this appeal and issue the requested variance, the city council would be required to find that by reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness or shape of the property, or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition of the property, the strict application of the terms of Chapter 50 would result in peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties to or exceptional or undue hardship upon the owner of such property and that such relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the intent of the zoning plan and the zoning Code; in addition the council must find that special circumstances or conditions applying to the building or land in question which are peculiar to such property or immediately adjoining property, and do not apply generally to other land or buildings in the vicinity, that the granting of the application is necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of a substantial property right and not merely to serve as a convenience to the applicant, and that authorizing of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light and air to adjacent property or unreasonably increase the congestion in public streets or increase the danger of fire or imperil the public safety or unreasonably diminish or impair established property values within the surrounding areas or in any other respect impair the health, safety, comfort, morals or general welfare of the inhabitants of the city.; and

        WHEREAS, the city council has considered this appeal and agrees with the decision of the board of zoning appeals that the granting of a variance to allow the construction of five dwellings on parcels of property by reducing the required lot area for 2 dwellings from 5,000 square feet to 3,000 square feet; 2 dwellings to 3,500 square feet and 1 dwelling to 3,600 square feet; to reduce the required frontage on a maintainable street for each lot from 50' to 30', 35' and 36' respectively; and to relax the front yard setback from 25' to 10', the corner side yard setback from 15' to 9, and the aggregate side yard setback from 12' to 10' cannot be made in this case.

        NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the city council hereby finds denying the requested variance would not create a hardship to the property in that no special circumstances apply to the property which are peculiar to that property or do not apply generally to other land in the vicinity and it is not necessary to grant the variance for the preservation and enjoyment of a substantial property right.

        FURTHER RESOLVED, by the city of Duluth that the board of zoning appeals' decision of July 24, 2001, is hereby affirmed by the city council, and the appeal is denied.



STATEMENT OF PURPOSE:  This resolution affirms the decision of the board of zoning appeals to deny a zoning variance to allow the construction of five dwellings on parcels of property reducing the required lot area for 2 dwellings from 5,000 square feet to 3,000 square feet; 2 dwellings to 3,500 square feet and 1 dwelling to 3,600 square feet; to reduce the required frontage on a maintainable street for each lot from 50' to 30', 35' and 36' respectively; and to relax the front yard setback from 25' to 10', the corner side yard setback from 15' to 9, and the aggregate side yard setback from 12' to 10' on property located at 5109-5119 Ramsey St. The council agreed with the board's findings that no physical characteristic peculiar to the property prevented the owner from exercising a substantial property right, and that granting a variance may result in negative impacts on the surrounding neighborhood. The council determined that granting a variance would violate the requirements of the sign ordinance and the zoning code.